Inasmuch as there has been a significant amount of attention placed on the issue of Haitians born in the Dominican Republic being stripped of certain rights by the Dominican Republic, overlooked and may be argued just as perverse is what appears to be systematic and apparently sanctioned trade abuses by the Dominican Republic government. This relates to the export of products into Haiti through gaps in the border shared by the two countries.
Case in point may be the case of poultry and eggs, where the Dominican Republic exports over 400 million eggs per year to Haiti through several of the more than 50 unofficial trading centers on the Dominican side of the border. While it is clear that there is need for products like poultry and eggs in Haiti, the possible dumping of unregulated, sometimes expired, untested and untaxed Dominican products undermines the concept of fair trade and denies the Haitian government much needed tax revenue.
Importantly, it also belies the argument that Haiti is open for business. A recent investment by Jamaica Broilers and local partners may well be an example of how the current situation conspires against an effort by investors in Haiti to build out a viable business. For the Haitian small farmer involved in poultry and egg production, the future, considering the possible unfair trade practices being employed, is bleak and could be catastrophic.
To be clear, the efforts of investors such as Haiti Broilers to produce hatchlings, feed, eggs and broilers for the local market cannot address the needs of a population of over eight million people. There is, as a result, space for many players, including legitimate Dominican exporters and/or investors. However, the current framework that apparently facilitates the illicit movement of unregulated goods can in no way be allowed to continue. In trade terms, the effective dumping of products into Haiti with the apparent blessing of the Dominican government needs to be checked before it destroys a nascent industry and the livelihood of small farmers. The situation can also be viewed as a red flag to other parties interested in investing in Haiti.
To be fair, the unwillingness or inability of the Haitian government to exercise controls and collect taxes on goods coming across the border serves to highlight a significant problem for Haiti. This however does not absolve the government of the Dominican Republic of responsibility for a situation where the unregulated trade of foodstuffs in locations that are unsanitary, is being conducted within its borders.
While there has been fanfare surrounding the recent signing of protocols by government officials of both countries on the issue of poultry and eggs, the lack of a regulatory system to ensure the quality of product remains. Licensing and certifying of facilities, health permits, and the storage and refrigerated transportation mechanisms needed to guarantee safe foodstuff remains unfunded. This, while it is argued, producers in the Dominican Republic continue to flood the weak border infrastructure.
Some solutions that have to be considered include increased support for border control and sanitary systems for Haitian authorities by the international donor community. Failure to support mechanisms to collect lost tax revenue allows for claims of the development community being complicit in perpetuating a system that will have Haiti as an unfettered market for products that may or may not meet international standards. Worse, it dooms those involved in agricultural production to unfair competition, as they are liable for import duties at the seaports they use to bring in necessary inputs while goods coming access the border are likely to enter freely.
Fundamentally for investor and small farmer alike, in the face of any trade abuse, the Haitian government will have to advance a system that protects local businesses from any alleged unfair practices. It has to also promote and incentivize the development of local industries that create employment and address food security. All this with the support of the development community that claims to be committed to seeing the country prosper.

o Anton Edmunds is the head of The Edmunds Group, a boutique business and government advisory service firm that focuses on the Caribbean, and a senior Associate at the Center for Strategic & International Studies (CSIS). He can be contacted by email here and prior posts reviewed at the firm's website: www.theedmundsgroup.com. Published with the permission of Caribbean News Now.

Click here to read more at The Nassau Guardian